#Art Hist 100 Feb 28 Notes
Question:
Iconography and Iconology Topic:
Iversne and Melville hav suggested that Erwin Panofsky favored an.....
###Key Objects
- Iconology and Iconography
- Historical Distance
- "Objectivity"
- Melville and Iversen
What do these things mean?
###Panofsky
And the foundations of Art History
Three steps to the method
- Pre-iconographic: (e.g Man and woman hold hands, dog near them, sunny outside)
- Conventional, iconographic(literary) (e.g Adam and Eve from the bible have separate snakes)
- Iconological phase: Generally first step is hitting the historical archives.
- The icon- in iconography and iconology is a symbol.
- Character from the Da-vinci code is a symbologist at Harvard(The department doesn't actually exist)
####Symbols
Example: Christ gives St.Peter the keys to the gates of Heaven
######Formalist:
- A man has blue robes, it has many shadows painted in it. A formal reading involves also analyzing his tunic, and how the colors between the robe and the tunic look together
######Iconographical: THIS IS JESUS.
#####Panofsky Essay Perspective as symbolic form
- Panofsky does an iconological reading of perspective.
- The neatline between form and symbol is muddy.
- An icon can be a set of lines, it doesn't have to be JESUS.
The point of iconography is you can't just approach a print and know what your seeing.
Iconography answers questions that form can't attend to
####Historical Distance
- In the past, much of history was already written in text(the bible).
- Panofsky operates on a more linear, German idea of history that moves better and forward from past to present.
- Panofsky believes that using Iconography is an objective method because it infers a context for specific icons.
- Nothing undermines the objectivity of panofsky's method but new information can come in and make a new consensus.
#####Interpretations of Objectivity
Panofsky lived under an Autocrat. He wanted to give art-historians a method to prevent ideaological appropiations of art and events.
Nazi's had the slogan "roots and soils"
- Panofsky wanted to make it very difficult for the Nazi's to make appropiations for various symbols and ideas.
- Whitney and Thadeus butt heads on the idea of objective truth. Thadeus pushes back against a singular, intrinsic objctive truth.
- For Panofsky artist intentions are deeply important.
Subjective and Objective should be thought of as a continum, on a spectrum.